” In The Name Of God – Go! “

The words of Oliver Cromwell addressing the English Parliament in 1653.

The full quotation is:” Depart I say, and let us have done with you. In the name of God, go!”

English: Statue of Oliver Cromwell

Oliver Cromwell - allowed the Jews to return to England

Some might think it ironic that I choose to quote Cromwell, considering that he was instrumental in permitting Jews to return to England after 600 years of exile. (N.B. He was not referring to Jews in this quote).

But I am!

After 63 years, the internecine strife between the different elements of Israeli society has finally reached breaking point. Of course, the signs have been there for decades, but it is only recently that matters have come to a head. Slowly, the battle lines are being drawn in the fight for the soul of Israel.

I am aware that these words may sound melodramatic and hyperbolic, but passion is what is needed if the country is not to become a religious fundamentalist mirror image of Iran. There, the policy is dictated by the Mullahs and the Imams. Do we want our policies to be determined by the Rabbis and leadership of the Haredim?

The very essence of secularism is tolerance, and a philosophy based on understanding and equality. This has been ruthlessly exploited by certain elements of Haredi society and enabled them to gain enormous influence and power, out of all proportion to the 10% of the population that they represent numerically.

Recent events in Beit Shemesh,  Mea Shearim  and on Egged buses have been widely publicised and do not need further elaboration here. Apologists argue that the violence is carried out by a handful of extremists who do not represent the Ultra orthodox as a whole. That may be true of the specific acts, but many Haredim are sympathetic to the ultimate objective; they just differ on the method.

Of course, the “Band-aid” merchants are running around in circles trying to patch up the wounds. They include the Prime Minister and a number of Rabbis and politicians, fearful of the consequences of total religious power.

Even allowing for a certain element of media hysteria, the irreconcilable differences should be finally acknowledged, and not swept under the carpet as they always have been. It is time to face the reality that Israel now comprises of at least 5 distinctly different societies:

  • The Haredim
  • The Nationalist or Traditional religious
  • The Secular (including atheists and agnostics) –  who are, supposedly, the majority.
  • The Arabs
  • The migrant workers, infiltrators and others.
The extent to which these groups can be moulded into a cohesive body – at least with some level of co-existence – is still being tested. With all its problems and imperfections, the multicultural experiment that is Israel, is not a total disaster. Not yet! But the future depends upon the willingness and desire of the groups to co-exist. In this respect most of the groups listed above generally demand more integration into the society. Only the Haredim seek less.
Interestingly, we are simply experiencing history repeating itself. Witness the following item:

“People often talk about David Ben Gurion’s encouragement of Haredi Jews to settle in Israel as his “greatest blunder.” Yet, not even he could foresee the damage the Haredim would cause in the future. Ben Gurion acknowledges the terrible mistake he made in a letter he wrote to his minister, Levi Eshkol, who would later become Israel’s Prime Minister.

English: David Ben Gurion, Israel's Prime Mini...

Ben-Gurion regrets........

Dear Eshkol:

I am not of the opinion that you need my advice in government matters and it is not my intention to lend such advice – however the rioting by religious fanatics exceeds all limits and I feel that I bear the responsibility to some degree. I exempted yeshiva students from doing military service. Indeed I did so when their numbers were small, but they have been steadily increasing and their lawlessness constitutes a danger to the state’s honor. We need not appear in the world as an Alabama or South Africa. I propose that every yeshiva student of age 18 and over who is apprehended at an illegal gathering, throwing rocks, attacking citizens or other acts of violence and hooliganism, should be recruited immediately into the IDF to serve like any other young Israeli, for the term of thirty months, not in the Ministry of Religions, but as a plain soldier. Generally, the entire question of yeshiva students should be examined and whether they should be exempt from military obligation; certainly law-breakers should not enjoy this dubious privilege . . ”  .http://rabbimichaelsamuel.com/

Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose.

(The more things change , the more they stay the same.)

Since its inception, Israel has tolerated and allowed to live in its midst, known religious opponents of the concept of Zionism and the very existence of the state. The Neturei Karta, and their new offshoot the Sicarii, have been regarded simply as extremist religious loonies. Even cosying up to Yasser Arafat and Mahmood Ahmedinijad was shrugged off as inconsequential nonsense.

Now the realisation is setting in that their worldview and the actions that stem from it, are , actually dangerous; not only to the targeted individuals, but to the very fabric of the state. All efforts to integrate them have failed, and are doomed to further failure in the future.
Perhaps now is the time to think the unthinkable. A Jewish state that invites Jews to leave!
Members of the Neturei Karta orthodox group pr...

Loonies in our midst.......

Maybe they should be encouraged to return to their Eastern European roots. Mentally and physically, in terms of dress and outlook, they never left them anyway. Is there another nation in the whole world that enables people to live within it who are committed to its total destruction? I think not. I am not sure how we translate the desire for them to leave into reality. Will asking them nicely work? Or can we be more forceful? At least to the point of paraphrasing Cromwell and saying to them:

“In the name of God – go!”

Andyboy – Telling it as it is

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s